Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Fantasy Literature and the Death Penalty

In most cases, I feel like I get my morals from a combination of real life, and reading fiction. Sometimes without even knowing it, an author will embed a moral lesson into a story, whereas other times, the moral is the point of the story. Usually, in fantasy and horror, my pleasure reading genres of choice, the former is true. A moral is there because the characters have human emotions, and those two things are inseparable, but not because the writer set out to teach an ethical lesson to the reader.
When I was younger, I based my views of the death penalty solely off of what I learned from reading these books. When you’re reading Harry Potter, there is no question that Voldemort needs to die— fully die— in order to ensure the safety of the world’s population. The same is true of King Leck in Graceling, Selia in The Goose Girl, Darquesse in Skulduggery Pleasant, and President Snow in The Hunger Games, to name only a few. Reading these stories, I never felt the characters would be truly safe until the threat was averted; the villain was dead. Of course, in most cases, they aren’t. Such is the nature of fantasy books: the villain will continue to reappear and cause more trouble until they are thoroughly vanquished. Fortunately for us, however, the nature of real life is quite different.
Our real life “villains”, the guilty criminals on death row, cannot dissipate their bodies or possess prison guards or charm judges into believing their crimes were accidental. The likelihood of escape from a life sentence in a high security prison is extremely low, and so the main objective of the death penalty as I saw it— protecting potential future victims— is fulfilled.
The moral principle I’ve relied on to inform my opinions on the death penalty since realizing this is primarily that of fairness, which, according to the yourmorals.org survey we did for this class, is my strongest moral standard. I come at the issue of fairness regarding the death penalty from two directions. The first one is conventional: In the anti-death penalty article I read, the author mentioned the issues of discrimination in our criminal justice system which skew the demographics of death row inmates to be predominantly poor and of color. It is unfair that rich criminals who can hire expensive lawyers should be more “deserving” of a lenient sentence.
My second point of opposition to the death penalty on the basis of fairness comes from my standpoint on punishment. Because I do not believe in a punitive afterlife, I hold that life in prison is actually a crueller sentence than death. Additionally, in the case of criminals who have killed several people, their own, single death would never be enough in retribution to make up, either mathematically or morally for the many they took.

The “usual” political division holds conservatives in favor of the death penalty and liberals against it. How does this compare to other issues of life and death, such as abortion, recreational hunting, war, suicide, and physician-assisted suicide?