Whenever I am asked— whether by college interviewers, or casually by my friends— what I would change about the world, given the chance, my mind always jumps immediately to gender. It is both widespread (I have never heard of a culture which did not have a gender system in place), and deeply ingrained in people around the world. Each and every one of us encounters gender numerous times a day, sometimes without even realizing it. What you wear, which bathroom you use, who you spend time with, what activities you engage in, and what you choose to put in and on your body are all examples of daily gendered choices that, through mass repetition and constant reiteration through the media, have become mores of our culture.
These gendered choices are not only obligatory in response to the threat of social hostility, they are obligatory because they are impossible to avoid: there are only two bathrooms, two clothing departments, the gray, macho deodorant, or the pastel floral one. A middle ground is not easily available to consumers, so anyone seeking it is forced to go well out of their way.
The logic supporting gender mores and expectations are quite similar to that supporting age hierarchies between students here at Blake: these expectations keep people organized and categorized. Just as you can guess the age of a Blake student by where they sit in the lunch room, in our society, we are taught to assume a person's gender based on the way they respond to gendered choices, for example whether or not they choose to shave their legs.
The logic supporting gender mores and expectations are quite similar to that supporting age hierarchies between students here at Blake: these expectations keep people organized and categorized. Just as you can guess the age of a Blake student by where they sit in the lunch room, in our society, we are taught to assume a person's gender based on the way they respond to gendered choices, for example whether or not they choose to shave their legs.
Apart from the daily struggle our society’s mores of gender cause for trans and gender non-conforming people, they also serve as a barricade between masculinity and femininity, making it acceptable, perhaps through the in-group psychology mentioned by Smith (when writing about the soccer fans who felt pleasure at seeing the pain of their rival’s fans) for each group to antagonize the other. In the current and historical situation, with cisgender* men holding power, this divide effectively intensifies sexism from both sides of the gender binary.
Instead of allowing ourselves to be separated, (and thus have one group perpetually “superior” to the other) I believe it would be beneficial to everyone for us to blur the lines of what is acceptable in terms of gendered behaviors. In the interest of a more moral society, a lack of restrictive boundaries, whether or not we choose to cross them, would create more cohesion between people of all genders, making our in-group larger and more diverse. I hypothesize that this added diversity would at least partially dull the negative effects of group think. Additionally, in destigmatizing the rejection of traditional gender roles, we could collectively open up the way for women in male-dominated fields, as well as making men more comfortable in female-dominated ones, and trans/gender non-conforming people more comfortable everywhere.
The mores of gender hold us all back in one way or another. I suggest we continue the difficult task of questioning them, and refuse to let them become limitations as to how we choose to live our lives.
Do you think gender dynamics are an issue of morality? In what way? How are people of different genders/sexes held to different moral standards? Do you think that our gender mores are “adapted” to our current moment in history? Have they ever been?
*“cis” meaning “on the same side” in latin, “cisgender” refers to a person whose biological sex is aligned with their internal gender identity. It is the linguistic opposite of transgender.
No comments:
Post a Comment