In seventh grade at her Catholic middle school, my mom had a classmate whom, for the purpose of this blog post, I shall call Jeff. Jeff was in the habit of causing class disruptions and aggravating teachers with his antics. My mom recalls that he was not a bad person, and speculates that perhaps he was simply too intelligent for the class, and terribly bored.
At this time at the school, there was a program commonly referred to as "electives"— a set of special classes that took place on Friday afternoons, which were generally adored by the student body.
One day in class, Jeff did something particularly inflammatory, and in retaliation the teacher called the class to order and raised a vote: should the entire class lose the privilege to participate in electives, or should Jeff be suspended?
Looking at the teacher's actions through the lens of Haidt's TED talk, I would not hesitate to say that her reaction must have been linked to her feeling that Jeff had violated the moral standard of authority in disrespecting his teacher as a superior. I would suppose that at least several of the students in the class felt the same way. Without wishing to generalize or stereotype unnecessarily, I will draw the faintest of connections between the school demographic and culture (Catholicism, which is generally associated with conservative values) and the readiness of its inhabitants to seek retribution for a breach of respect for authority.
Some of the class, my mom included, however, felt that the teacher's actions were inappropriate. She was attempting to punish Jeff not only through the threat of suspension, but also through inciting the anger of his peers and the consequential embarrassment for Jeff. When the time came to vote, however, whether due to the moral standard of group loyalty, or the probably related and more often-cited phenomenon of group think, only two students raised their hands to vote to lose electives. My mom was ashamed of herself for voting to suspend Jeff, and impressed by the students who voted selflessly.
In the end, my mom does not remember whether or not Jeff got suspended, but she knows that her class never lost their elective classes. To this day, she remembers the names of the two students who voted the way she wished she had.
Who do you think is right, in this situation, the teacher? The students who voted in favor of Jeff? Those who voted against him? What else could have been done? What would you have done?
No comments:
Post a Comment